News & Commentary
  • Home
  • About Us
  • About Unschooling
  • Our Magazine
    • Next Issue Preview
    • Feature Articles
    • Subscibe
    • Digital Login
    • Write For HEM
    • Advertise
  • Consultants
    • Teresa Brett
    • Leslie Potter
    • Pat Farenga
    • Dayna Martin
    • Michelle Barone
    • Blake Boles
    • Kevin C Neece
  • Good Stuff
    • Audio Interviews
    • Videos
    • Book Reviews
    • Product Reviews
    • Unschooling Blogs
    • Free Book Offer
    • Books We Like
  • Support
    • Consultants
    • Our Magazine
    • Our e-Newsletter
  • News
    • News & Commentary
    • State News
    • Federal News
    • International News
  • Contact Us
    • General Inquiry
    • Editor
    • Subscriptions
    • Apply to be a Product Reviewer
    • Advertising

Does the Citizen Belong to the State?

In response to a reply in the New York Times about the article, “Home Schoolers Content to Take Children’s Lead,” a college professor questions to whom citizens “belong.”

Does the Citizen Belong to the State?, 3 August 2007, Market Correction blog

Even if you agree with Prof. Huerta’s dubious assumption that the state is a better judge than are parents of how, and for what purposes, children should be educated, what schooling alternative does the professor propose? Government schooling?

posted by Valerie

Aug 17 2007 in Politics, Unschooling valerieTags: home education, homeschooling, New York Times, Unschooling, Weblogs
3 Comments »

3 responses to Does the Citizen Belong to the State?

  1. Silvia said on August 23, 2007

    No, we don’t! Here’s a nice article called “The Central Fallacy of Public Schooling” from the Foundation for Economic Education: http://www.fee.org/publications/the-freeman/article.asp?aid=4846 . I use it on my blog–”My children do not belong to the state.”

    Reply
  2. Valerie said on August 23, 2007

    Thanks for the link to the article, Silvia, and the link to your blog :) ))
    (at last! someone who pronounced calzone properly!)

    Reply
  3. Silvia said on August 24, 2007

    My pleasure!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

«We’re from the government, and we’re here to help you
How much parental involvement in a child’s education is too much?»

Stories We Are Following

  • Common Core Standards
  • Romeike Family Asylum
  • Tebow Bills
  • Compulsory Attendance
  • Public School at Home
  • State Legislation
  • Alabama
  • Illinois
  • North Carolina
  • Tennessee
  • Texas

More News

  • State News
  • Federal News
  • International News
  • Reasons to Homeschool
  • Successful Homeschoolers
  • Politics
  • Sports

Resource Guide

Become a part of our Resource Guide

Art
  • Little Acorn Learning
Books
  • History Adventures
  • The New 3R's - Burns
Chemistry
  • Home Training Tools
Children's Magazines
  • Skipping Stones
Colleges
  • Central Christian College of the Bible
  • Evergreen State College
  • Bard College
  • Goddard College
  • Antioch University
  • Hampshire College
  • Hillsdale College
  • Prescott College
  • Reed College
  • St. John's College
  • University of CA at Berkeley
  • Brown University
  • MIT
  • No College!
  • Zero tuition College
Computer Science
  • Computer Programming for Kids
Conferences
  • Trailblazer Gathering
  • Life Rocks
  • Rethinking Everything
Educational Supplies
  • Lifetime Learning Companion
Family Vacations
  • Camp Common Ground
Foreign Language
  • Homeschool Spanish
  • Rosetta Stone
Games
  • Northstar Puzzle
Geography
  • USA Geography Quiz
History
  • History Resources
  • Lies My Teacher Told Me
  • Zinn Education Project
Home School Curriculum
  • The Keystone School
  • Oak Meadow
Literature
  • Literature Resources
Mathematics
  • Math Round Up
  • Sum Power Game
Music
  • Guitar Smith Online
  • Music on the Bookshelf
Online Programs
  • Free Audio - Video Stories
Online Schools
  • FLVS Global
  • Explorations Academy Online
Parenting Support
  • Touch the Future
Reading Instruction
  • The Reading Gym
Science
  • Hands on Science Kits
  • The Story of Cotton
  • Young Naturalist Awards
  • Weather For Kids
Self-Employment Education
  • Finding Your Niche
Summer Programs
  • Cornell University Summer College
Support Groups
  • State Laws
Testing/Assessments
  • SAT/ACT/AP Prep
Travel
  • Travel Ideas
Unschooling
  • unschoolers.org
  • Unschool Family Counseling
  • Unschooling
  • The Unschool Experiment
Writing Programs
  • Incite to Write

Become a part of our Resource Guide

  • Copyright © 2013
  • Go back to top ↑
Network - HEM
  • Log In
  • Blog Authors
    • HEM
    • Helen
    • Mark
    • marynix
    • ann-lahrson-fisher
    • valerie
    • sandi
    • monikab
    • jessicap
    • Susan
  • Visit
    • Random Member
    • Random Site
HEM Network, Home Education Magazine Digital 2012