The Change Has Already Occurred

For a couple of this past week’s posts I focused on mainstream news stories relating to homeschooling, and more than once I alluded to a post I’ve been working on which will, hopefully, tie some loose ends together for my readers. Among the issues I wrote about were an all men’s leadership conference scheduled for next March, a silly comment from an ex-schoolteacher turned comedienne on a daytime talk show, and a Washington Post article by Kathleen Parker, which, while not directly about homeschooling, effectively points out one of the biggest problems facing homeschooling families in the months and years ahead. If you haven’t read these posts yet, you might want to do so, and read the links they point to for a better understanding before continuing here.

With the 2008 elections, there has been a rearranging of the political landscape in this country, and a shift of power is in the offing, as suggested in the article by Kathleen Parker. The challenge for us as homeschooling families and advocates has always been how to keep homeschooling from being aligned with a specific ideology, and understanding why that is important, and what effect it will have on our ability to continue to protect, defend, and expand our homeschooling freedoms, and those of our children and grandchildren.

The 1991 series of essays titled “Homeschooling Freedoms at Risk,” referred to in one of my comments, outlined how a specific group of businesses and individuals deliberately destroyed the networks of support and communication which created the early homeschooling movement. But what many people have failed to understand is that, at bottom, those actions had only had a tangential relationship to homeschooling. The overarching goal was to bring together a constituency which would support and expand a specific world view, and to help place that world view into the highest seats of power in this country. Homeschooling families were turned into pawns in a political chess game; how often did we hear chest-thumping claims from HSLDA about how many homeschoolers they could call into action?

I’d like to share an excerpt from a source unlikely to be quoted on a homeschooling blog: Esquire: The Magazine for Men. An article in their October issue, endorsing Barack Obama, included this paragraph:

“More than any other recent election, we are voting this year not merely for a president but to overthrow two governments. The one we can see is the one in which constitutional order has been defaced, the national spirit degraded, and the country unrecognizable because so much of the best of itself has been sold off or frittered away. The other one is the far more insidious one, a doppelgänger nation of black prisons, shredded memos, and secret justifications for even more secret crimes. Moreover, the current administration has worked hard not only to immunize itself from the political and legal consequences of the government we can see, but it has also worked within the one we cannot see in order to perpetuate itself.”

What does that have to do with homeschooling? Just this, in the very next paragraph:

“For the past several months, it has worked to make extricating ourselves from the catastrophe it has wrought in Iraq as hard as possible. It has sought to make permanent the culture of corporate brigandage and predatory incompetence that it has made a hallmark of its stewardship of the country and its government. Salted throughout the vast bureaucracy are dozens of little homeschooled land mines, the products of a dozen cheapjack diploma mills selling patent-medicine history to the spiritually gullible. The fantastical hiring practices that only recently have come to light in the Department of Justice are only the most visible example of this, but the poisonous philosophy that has guided this administration is in all the institutions of the government Barack Obama hopes to lead. It is not dormant. It is there, replicating itself like a virus does in the cells of the body, waiting until it can erupt and debilitate him and his administration.”

Read that middle sentence again: “Salted throughout the vast bureaucracy are dozens of little homeschooled land mines, the products of a dozen cheapjack diploma mills…”

The attitude exhibited in this writing is the direct legacy of those businesses and individuals outlined in “Homeschooling Freedoms at Risk” 18 years ago. As homeschoolers, the fears we expressed then about aligning ourselves with non-homeschoooling issues, thereby threatening our homeschooling freedoms, are being met. This is not a “We told you so” statement, but simply a reality we all need to understand and take action to address.

We cannot ignore the central role religion has played in the process of aligning homeschooling with the political ambitions of the few and their narrow ideology. The future of homeschooling has been compromised, and homeschooling has been thrust into the federal spotlight, where it should never have been. But as unfortunate as that is, the far worse consequence is the way in which personal religious beliefs have been usurped and drafted into political servitude. The homeschooling community has had a front row seat to this politicization of religion, starting with the actions described in “Freedoms at Risk”:

“The proponents of exclusivism are wreaking havoc in state after state by breaking down lines of communication, circumventing effective network building, weakening existing networks, imposing artificial organizational structures, co-opting individual responsibility and fostering a dependency on outside groups and individuals. There’s a definite pattern, a self-perpetuating cycle that supports exclusive groups, locking many homeschoolers out of new networks and driving others from existing networks. The formation of this exclusive hierarchy brings the complex underlying issues of religious intolerance and domination into the homeschool community.”

This brings us right back to Kathleen Parker’s article in this week’s Washington Post:

“…like it or not, we are a diverse nation, no longer predominantly white and Christian. The change Barack Obama promised has already occurred, which is why he won.”

The change has already occurred.

The post here earlier this week which pointed out next year’s purported “leadership” conference generated a comment and a link to Mary Nix’s blog, The Informed Parent, where she wrote a good post under the heading “How Do We Combat the Prevailing Fear?” An excerpt:

“Looking at the homeschool alarms from some who continue to claim that the President elect will end homeschooling as we know it reminds me of similar warnings I’ve read after most elections. I do believe that we need to remain vigilant, that we should always be on watch to ensure our rights are not taken, but I do believe that we must investigate the threats ourselves to see if they are substantial or exaggerated.

“With that said, I am concerned at how some churches and religious groups have reacted this time around. It seems the fears that they were facing before the election are growing and I am worried that their fears will continue to divide us rather than unite us. For example, I don’t ever recall churches proclaiming that if you voted a certain way you were no longer or couldn’t ever have been a member of a certain faith? Nor do I recall church members being told they could not partake in that churches communion if you voted for a particular person, but I have been reading about both these scenarios since the election.

Remember the silly outburst by the talk show comedienne who remarked that a lot of homeschoolers are “demented?” Her comment provoked a call to boycott ABC programming. However “demented” her comment may have been, it is another indication of a too widely held perception of homeschoolers inhabiting the lunatic fringes of society, but that perception is no longer limited to ex-schoolteachers and comedians. The incident has created a small firestorm of distancing oneself from homeschooling, as home education pundit Daryl Cobranchi asks in a post titled “I Am So Embarrassed,” “Is it possible to secede from the ‘homeschool movement?'”

Likewise, homeschooling dad Chris O’Donnell emblazoned his blog with the disclaimer: “I’m not one of ‘those’ homeschoolers.” And his post on the subject of the aforementioned comedienne’s gaffe… well… it’s not for polite company, but he too disavows any further identification with homeschooling families.

I think this is a big mistake, because homeschoolers as a whole should not be so summarily dismissed. Larry and Susan Kaseman described homeschooling families very well in their Taking Charge column for the Nov-Dec issue of Home Education Magazine:

“…Homeschoolers come in all shapes and sizes. The only thing we all agree on is the decision to take responsibility for our children’s education ourselves rather than sending them to a conventional school. That said, we differ on everything else, starting with education. We choose different curriculums, approaches to learning, methods of education, ways of evaluating learning, and more. Then we have differing perspectives on and beliefs about religion, live a wide range of different lifestyles, come from many different cultural backgrounds and economic circumstances.”

Just so.

What we need to do is simply, as Mary Nix so well defines it, “combat the prevailing fear.”

To that end, I’d like to leave you with a suggestion for further reading: The Kaseman’s column, titled “Keeping Homeschooling Nonpartisan.”

“…We need to focus on the strengths that come from being a varied, grassroots movement that works together to maintain the basic freedom each family needs.”

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

3 Responses to The Change Has Already Occurred

  1. cod on November 24, 2008 at 4:38 pm

    Helen, Helen, Helen :)

    You didn’t read all the way to the bottom of my page did you? Allow me to quote my disclaimer…

    This is a personal blog. Anything expressed here is at best my opinion and my opinion only. I’m not above making stuff up to start a conversation, so you are probably better off just not taking anything I write here too seriously. Comments are owned by whoever posted them.

  2. Helen on November 24, 2008 at 4:52 pm

    LOL, Daryl! Well… You’ve gotta admit quoting you lent credibility to my argument, eh?

  3. Mary Nix on November 29, 2008 at 8:29 am

    I really enjoyed the Kaseman’s article. Two statements caught my eye.

    “–Homeschoolers save taxpayers a great deal of money. If all the current homeschoolers enrolled in public schools, the cost of public education would increase.”

    In my state of Ohio, the cybercharter enrollment grew by leaps and bounds the first couple of years. When looking at the cost of public education that had sharply risen in a senate finance committee meeting, the senators blamed those growing costs on homeschoolers. OHEC and others have had to continually listen, watch and contact the media and the legislature to let them know many home educators remain independent and are not the ones causing the increase.

    –Homeschoolers do not want money from the government in the form of tax credits, tax deductions, or outright grants. We do not want other special favors. We realize that there’s no such thing as a free lunch and we do not want the increased state regulation that would accompany such favors.

    When some of the same cyberschools and the cyberschool learned that their funding was being cut a few years back, they began calling the legislature asking them not to cut their “homeschool funding.” In response, I attended a Senate finance hearing with OHEC Co-coordinator, Peggy Daly Masternak. The crowd was so large that they asked for folks to pick one person to represent each group that was attending. Peggy spoke for OHEC. Before they opened the floor, the Chairman stated that due to the crowd, testimony would be limited to five minutes. They asked Peggy to speak first as we were the only group that involved independent homeschoolers. Peggy is an excellent speaker and shared her response easily in the five minute allotted time. After that, the committee continued to ask her question after question and kept her up there for a good twenty minutes. They thanked her profusely for reminding them that there was a big difference between home education in our state and those who used the cyber charters at home.

    I hope others will take the time to read the article as well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Do you have a question?
We have several answers!

Search HEM's 10,000+ page knowledge base.

Home Education Magazine

Home Education Magazine is available by subscription in either print, digital, or a combined format.

(Preview a digital sample.)

Subscribe Today

Print - One Year Sub $26.00
Print - Two Year Sub $48.00
Digital - One Year Sub $13.00
Digital & Print - One Year Sub $36.00
Print US domestic only. HEM is no longer accepting print subs to foreign addresses.

Since 1983 Home Education Magazine has been a trusted name in homeschooling.

RSS Home Education Magazine

  • Class Dismissed: A Film About Learning Outside the Classroom
    An HEM Interview between filmmaker Jeremy Stuart and HEM’s editor, Barb Lundgren, published in HEM’s September-October 2014 issue From home study and kitchen table math, to perpetual recess and park days, Class Dismissed follows the story of an ordinary American family in their quest to educate their children outside the school system. As they struggle […]

RSS Homeschooling

RSS News & Commentary

  • Wisconsin Virtual Academy Must Adhere to Public School Requirements
    Wisconsin Virtual Academy Must Adhere to Public School Requirements Over the years, there has been intentional word mixing by some officials in order to draw independent homeschoolers back into the public schools.  Across the board, confusion often reigns as to who or who is not a homeschooler.  It usually lies on the homeschool community’s back […]

RSS HEM Resources

  • Hands On Science Kits
    Hands On Science Kits Tumblehome Learning, helps kids imagine themselves as young scientists or engineers and encourages them to experience science through adventure and self-guided discovery. Exciting mystery Adventure Fun experiments Hands On Science Kits All carefully designed to engage students. Learn more about how to engage and satisfy your kids scientific curiosity GO to […]

RSS HEM Groups

  • Staying Informed
    Staying Informed The issues facing homeschoolers today are fundamentally the same as 30 years ago when HEM was first published. While communication is easier the underlying social question is, can parents be trusted with their kids? Our political positions will support this answer in the affirmative. But this is not always the case nor is it […]